November 14, 2007.
So almost two months after I had my battle-cry-tantrum-calling-out-copy-cats, a portion of an article I wrote has been published. I say "portion" because the article is published under the "Letters to the Editor" section in the trade magazine Kids Today.
Not one to look a gift horse in the mouth I am greatful for the press.....however the published article is only a skeleton, or a weak version of my original article. Feel free to read the published article here, or you can read what I submitted here:
Buyers Beware! Is your Monet real or a fake?
By Jamie Risdon Lentzner
Founder & Artist, Jamie's Painting & Design
"Imitation is the highest form of flattery"….We tend to disagree! Please stay original! Copying is not polite. We are thrilled that you appreciate our work….and we would be very happy if you respect our copyrights!"
Disclaimer Shelly Kennedy, Drooz Studios ™
Who am I?
As a veteran of the children's manufacturing industry, with almost five years under my belt, I have seen the industry change. When I started Jamie's Painting & Design there were no theme based letters on the market. After painting ceramics tiles myself, I then had all of my friends request them and realized I was on to something. I have weathered many different styles, influences, sales channels, and I have seen the Internet mature as a resource for the consumer.
In 2002 I started Jamie's Painting & Design in a so-called vacuum. Having been in the Children's Educational software industry for several years prior, and having a background in cartooning, my professional experience was developing characters, and designing games. At the time of my departure from animation, it did not even occur to me at the time to research ideas, or styles - I used my two very young children, friend's nurseries and my own ideas as inspiration for my first products. Fast-forward to 2005, I came to realize that people can find out quite a bit about an artist, a designer or a product on line. I have had my share of dealing with plagiarism, and the stealing of my ideas. Plagiarism is a “dirty little secret” in our industry, it exists, it’s not going away, and it is not a topic of discussion in an open forum.
Bittersweet Success
Being an innovator is not always a rewarding pedestal to sit on top of. Shelly Kennedy, of Drooz Studio™ is very familiar with our industry’s “dirty little secret”. Having been in business for over ten years, she created the first original wall hanging. When she started Drooz she was one of the only artists out there. Shelly's designs are some of the most coveted products for celebrities and stores in the industry,
"We have had a number of customers and designers call to inquire about our products….they tell us how much they love our products, how talented we are and they can't wait to purchase their first piece! They ask to be put on our mailing list…and then miraculously a new company pops up and it is that very "customer" making products that look just like ours. This hurts. I pride myself on honestly - I just can't understand how people could be so blatantly manipulative”, says Shelly
Competition is a good thing; in fact, it is the whole basis for keeping you on your toes as an innovator. However, dealing with copycats is a whole different can of worms - it derails your creativity, it hijacks your energy, causing you to lose focus on your business, and spend more time wondering why someone could sleep at night thinking that they have done something good.
"What is the worst is when a so-called 'Mompreneur' takes your idea and tries to copy it as their own. It really knocks the wind out of you" says, Leslie Head, co-founder of TeePee for Me ™.
London Edwards, owner of My Little Dish is very familiar with this situation,
"A particular artist did not hesitate to paint the exact same themes, even my original trademarked Prayer Plate™ found it's way into her line and she ambushed every account I had with a cheaper priced plate."
Every artist I have spoken with has had the exact same response - a knock-off artist is always a day late and a dollar short. And more importantly, even if it took a while for an artisan to get back on track, they ALWAYS got back on track - they had to. Katy Mimari, founder of Caden Lane and a trail blazer in the modern bedding industry says;
"When we introduced Caden Lane Bedding to the market three years ago there was a lack of modern baby accessories available to the young, hip mothers…..we were the first to introduce the "pink & brown" color combination that is now found in almost EVERY designer’s collection today."
Joannie Perales, a jewelry designer and founder of Fairy Tale Jewels© claims that,
"Independent ‘artists’ reworking my designs, it's an ongoing issue that I have had to deal with since I first began beading…some call this "inspiration", I call it being a knock off."
With so many companies in the industry fighting for a sale, it easy to see how buyers and store owners can be overwhelmed and confused, but buying quality art and products is what sets you apart from the big box stores and the lower end retailers.
How It Impacts the Retailer?
A small boutique or even a large chain of children's stores looks to make an investment in their inventory, or for personalized samples. The minimums can range anywhere from $200 to upwards of thousands of dollars to open an account (for the small boutique just starting out, this can equate to a significant amount of money). If that initial purchase is based on emotion - “I just love your stuff”, or based on a PR ballooned up product – “my products are in magazines, so you should not waste any time buying from me”, you are more than likely not getting what you think you are getting.
Buyers should interview the artist who's work they are considering for their merchandising space. Remember, we work for you; we make products for you to sell to your customer base. Asking questions of the artisan as to why they are in the industry…
· How often do you release new themes or designs?
· How long have you been in business for?
· What are your turnaround times? (This one is very important, as this helps you set expectations with your customer)
· Do you have a background, professional and/or educational, as it relates to art?
More importantly is how a new company or new artist deals with customer service. An established company with 500 accounts and a strong track record of meeting their delivery dates will be worth the research you did. Keep in mind, your customer does not know who is making the product, they do remember the store they had the experience at. Don’t be afraid to ask for references, personally, I encourage it.
Lauren Headstrom, owner of Personalized Gift Stop in Los Altos
California
has had her share of problems with new artisans,
"It's hard when you are a buyer, and you want to find the next best thing, you are always looking for something unique for your store. For a lot of us independently owned stores we pride ourselves on being different…..I always want to help someone out that is brand new, but I am wary of new companies, I have had some go away after I purchased samples, or not return my calls when I re-ordered."
Last, and most importantly is making sure the company you ‘partner’ with has Liability Insurance. There is a remote chance that something could go sideways, although, in my 5 years in the business, I have not heard of it happening. This is one place where someone who is in our industry for a quick dollar gives no consideration to something like insurance, and that is extremely important.
At the End of the Day
Consumers and especially new moms have become savvy shoppers, very educated on the latest styles, trends, and especially the designers, and the artists. With the Internet, consumers can easily research products on line in the leisure of their own home.
When someone knocks-off our designs it forces us to look long and hard at our own business, designs, practices and it makes us work that much harder. It forces us to not be good, but be the best we can.
"A true creative person has so many endless ideas stored in their head and sketch books, there is never a need to copy ideas from others…" says, Shelly Kennedy.
At one low point in recent times I confided in Vicki Bodwell, owner and founder of Warm Biscuit Bedding© about my frustration on this subject, she said,
"Don't focus on it, you can't be everything to everybody, just do what you do best."
So, there it is, the published article and the one I wrote. I would like to personally thank everyone who agreed to be apart of the "article" that was uh, not really an article. I am sorry you had to take time out of your busy lives to answer my questions - I wish the article had all the Industry Leaders (you know who you are) refferenced in the article. The saying no press is bad press....we will see, we will see.
Recent Comments